The Enchanting Life, Dramatic Second Act, and Sudden Loss of Television’s Favorite Witch
For anyone who grew up during the golden age of American television, the mere mention of Elizabeth Montgomery triggers an instant, almost nostalgic auditory response: the gentle, magical chime that accompanied the signature twitch of a nose.
As Samantha Stephens on the classic 1960s sitcom Bewitched, Montgomery didn’t just play a character—she became a global phenomenon, bringing warmth, elegance, and effortless wit into millions of living rooms every week.
Yet long after the soundstages of suburban Connecticut were packed away, Montgomery executed one of the most remarkable career pivots in Hollywood history, trading lighthearted comedy for gritty drama before her life was cut tragically short in 1995.
Born to Hollywood Royalty
Acting was coded into Montgomery’s DNA from the very beginning. Born in Los Angeles on April 15, 1933, to Broadway actress Elizabeth Allen and acclaimed film star and director Robert Montgomery, she grew up on the periphery of Tinseltown’s inner circle.
Despite her privileged upbringing, she knew early on that she wanted to earn her place on the stage and screen under her own power.
“Dad tells me I often climbed on his lap after dinner and remarked, ‘I’m going to be an actress when I grow up,'” Montgomery recalled in a 1954 interview with the Los Angeles Times. “I don’t know whether he encouraged me or not, but he told me he would humor me and would tell me to wait and see what happened.”
[ THE LIFE & CAREER OF ELIZABETH MONTGOMERY ]
1933 ─── Born in Los Angeles to Hollywood legend Robert Montgomery.
1953 ─── Makes Broadway debut in "Late Love"; enters film in 1955.
1963 ─── Marries director William Asher; lands starring role in "Bewitched."
1964 ─── "Bewitched" premieres, running for 8 iconic seasons until 1972.
1974 ─── Reinvents career in "A Case of Rape," earning the title "Queen of TV Movies."
1995 ─── Passes away at 62 from cancer, leaving behind an indelible legacy.
After refining her craft at New York’s prestigious Spence School and the American Academy of Dramatic Arts, a teenage Montgomery made her professional television debut on her father’s anthology series, Robert Montgomery Presents.
Though she acknowledged that her father’s influence opened doors—calling him her “most severe critic, but also a true friend”—her natural talent was undeniable. By 1953, she was starring on Broadway in Late Love, followed by her feature film debut in 1955’s The Court-Martial of Billy Mitchell.
A Spellbound World: The Bewitched Era
Throughout the late 1950s and early 1960s, Montgomery showcased her versatility in high-profile anthology shows like The Twilight Zone, Alfred Hitchcock Presents, and The Untouchables. But everything changed when she crossed paths with director and TV producer William Asher.
The two married in 1963, forming a creative and romantic partnership that would birth one of television’s most enduring triumphs.
When Bewitched premiered on ABC in 1964, it was an immediate rating juggernaut. As Samantha Stephens, a suburban witch trying to live a normal mortal life alongside her mortal husband, Darrin, Montgomery brought an effortless, grounded charm to a surreal premise.
Unlike many of her contemporaries, who relied heavily on intricate makeup and elaborate styling, Montgomery possessed a luminous, natural beauty that radiated through the screen.
“I’d never thought much about a series because I liked the idea of picking a script I liked with a character I thought I could sustain,” Montgomery told the Associated Press in 1965. “In a series, you live with one character day in and day out—and you only hope it will be one that will not drive you crazy.”
Over eight seasons and 254 episodes, Montgomery earned five Primetime Emmy nominations and four Golden Globe nominations, transforming her famous wiggle-of-the-nose into a timeless pop-culture motif.
Reigning as the “Queen of the TV Movie”
When Bewitched wrapped in 1972—and her marriage to Asher ended around the same time—industry insiders wondered if Montgomery would be forever typecast as the sweet-natured suburban witch. Instead, she embarked on a daring second act that redefined television movies throughout the 1970s, 80s, and 90s.
She tackled groundbreaking, gritty, and often dark roles that were light-years removed from Samantha Stephens:
-
Mrs. Sundance (1973): A western drama where she met actor Robert Foxworth, who would become her long-time partner and eventually her husband in 1993.
-
A Case of Rape (1974): A landmark, highly acclaimed drama that challenged societal perceptions surrounding sexual assault and earned her critical raves.
-
The Legend of Lizzie Borden (1975): A chilling portrayal of the infamous accused axe murderer, proving her ability to carry intense, complex historical drama.
-
Black Widow Murders (1993) & The Corpse Had a Familiar Face (1994): Gritty crime thrillers that showcased her razor-sharp dramatic instinct in her later years.
“Before Jane Seymour, before Lindsay Wagner, and before Valerie Bertinelli, Elizabeth was the first Queen of the TV movies,” noted pop-culture biographer Herbie J Pilato. “She went from queen of the witches to queen of the TV movie, and it was no longer a struggle to break away from Bewitched.”
Reflecting on her career choices in a 1992 interview, Montgomery noted that the unpredictability was entirely by design:
“They all have different kinds of ‘feels’ to them, and that’s probably one of the reasons why I’ve done them. I get letters from people saying one of the things they like best about what I’ve done since Bewitched is that they never know what I’m going to do next.”
A Quiet Battle and an Untimely Farewell
In early 1995, while filming Deadline for Murder: From the Files of Edna Buchanan, Montgomery began experiencing severe fatigue and abdominal pain. Having previously fought cancer and believing she was in the clear, she initially brushed off the symptoms as exhaustion.
By the time she sought comprehensive medical evaluations in March 1995, the prognosis was grim: doctors discovered advanced liver cancer that had spread too far for aggressive treatment.
Choosing to spend her remaining days in peace rather than in a hospital ward, Montgomery retired to her Beverly Hills home. On May 18, 1995, at the age of 62, she passed away quietly in her sleep, surrounded by her husband, Robert Foxworth, and her three children.
A month later, friends, family, and colleagues gathered for a memorial service at the Canon Theatre in Beverly Hills. Jazz legend Herbie Hancock performed, while her lifelong friend, author Dominick Dunne, spoke affectionately about their early days as struggling young artists in New York City.
An Unpretentious Legacy
In an industry often defined by fleeting trends and superficial glamour, Elizabeth Montgomery stood out for her grounded authenticity, unpretentious warmth, and ferocious talent.
“Elizabeth was the least arrogant star I’ve ever met,” Herbie J Pilato reflected. “She channeled that down-to-earthiness into Samantha, and we all loved her for it.”
Whether she was twitching her nose to clear a chaotic living room or delivering a raw, dramatic performance in a telefilm, Montgomery brought a singular magic to the screen. Decades after her passing, her legacy endures as a shining emblem of television’s golden era—a reminder of a time when joy, grace, and enchantment were just a flick of the nose away.