The tight-knit pageant and local community of American Fork, Utah, has been plunged into deep mourning following the heartbreaking news of the sudden, unexpected death of Brynn Carnesecca—a former titleholder remembered as much for her selfless service and journalistic talent as her grace under the spotlight.
Two years after earning the crown of Miss American Fork 2024, Carnesecca’s passing has triggered a wave of emotional tributes from family members, close friends, and fellow contestants across the state.
Her family has chosen not to publicly disclose the specific cause of her death, focusing instead on celebrating a life defined by music, storytelling, and an unyielding commitment to spreading kindness.
To help navigate the sudden tragedy, her cousin, Kassidy Jackman Murdoch, launched a official GoFundMe campaign on behalf of the grieving family. The funds raised are earmarked to cover immediate funeral expenses, support the family through their grief, and establish a permanent memorial honoring Carnesecca’s legacy.
Demonstrating the profound impact she had on those around her, the campaign quickly gained traction, raising nearly $17,000 toward its $20,000 goal within days of launching.
A Life of Storytelling, Music, and Kindness
Behind the sparkling tiara and formal sash was a young woman with a remarkably diverse array of talents and passions. Carnesecca was an accomplished classical pianist, an aspiring journalist, and a dedicated community advocate.
"Brynn Carnesecca was more than just my cousin—she was a bright light in our family and community. As an accomplished pianist, journalist, and the creator of Envelopes of Hope, Brynn dedicated herself to sharing stories and spreading kindness."
Kassidy Jackman Murdoch writing on behalf of the family.
Driven by a desire to uplift others, Carnesecca founded Envelopes of Hope, a community initiative designed to share inspiring personal stories, deliver handwritten messages of encouragement, and foster empathy throughout her hometown and beyond.
Her passion for connection was evident in everything she touched—whether she was covering local news, performing at the piano, or representing her town at official civic events.
“Our family is heartbroken by Brynn’s unexpected passing,” her cousin added. “We want to honor her memory in a way that reflects her spirit and the love she gave to so many. Brynn touched countless lives through her work and her generosity, and we hope to celebrate her legacy with a meaningful memorial.”
Honored by Her Peers: The Spirit of Miss Congeniality
Carnesecca first stepped into the statewide spotlight when she earned the title of Miss American Fork 2024 through the Miss Utah Scholarship Organization—a prestigious program that provides academic scholarships while serving as a direct pipeline to the Miss Utah competition.
Throughout her reign, she threw herself into public service, supporting charitable causes, mentoring young girls, and serving as a proud ambassador for her city.
When she advanced to compete on the state stage at the 2025 Miss Utah competition, her genuine warmth and supportive nature earned her one of the pageant’s highest honors: the Miss Congeniality Award.
Voted on exclusively by her fellow contestants, the award recognizes the individual who brings the most positive energy, friendship, and encouragement to the behind-the-scenes atmosphere of the competition.
In a formal statement released following her passing, the Miss Utah Scholarship Organization expressed its profound sorrow:
-
Bringing Light: The organization noted that Carnesecca “brought so much light” to every single program she touched.
-
A Lasting Legacy: Leaders praised her unshakeable “kindness, friendship and service,” extending their deepest condolences, thoughts, and prayers to her family during this dark time.
Remembering a Legacy of Service
As family, friends, and pageant colleagues continue to process the loss, the focus remains firmly on preserving the joyful, compassionate spirit that defined Brynn Carnesecca’s life.
Through her musical performances, her journalistic efforts, her “Envelopes of Hope” project, and the countless lives she touched as Miss American Fork, her legacy endures as a powerful testament to the impact one dedicated individual can have on an entire community.